Friend or Foe

Saugerties, New York | Film Short

Drama

Regina Sobel

1 Campaigns |

28 days :00 hrs :06 mins

Until Deadline

40 supporters | followers

Enter the amount you would like to pledge

$
%

$2,485

Goal: $15,000 for production

A failed dancer, sleepwalking through a life she never wanted, reconnects with an estranged friend from the world she left behind — forcing her to face everything she’s spent years trying not to feel.

About The Project

  • The Story
  • Wishlist
  • Updates
  • The Team
  • Community

Mission Statement

There are so many movies about chasing your dreams, but what happens when it doesn’t work out? Inspired by my own struggle after I gave up on a dance career, FRIEND OR FOE is an exploration of failure and friendship that aims to help audiences process their own grief about life’s disappointments.

The Story


CHLOE is dreading BOBBI’S birthday weekend. In their college dance program these two women were inseparable, but they’ve been estranged ever since Chloe quit dancing and Bobbi moved out of the city.


When Chloe arrives at Bobbi's country house, she realizes to her horror that she's the only guest. Now she has to absorb Bobbi’s manic, theatrical personality on her own. Did Bobbi plan it this way?


Despite mounting anxiety, Chloe trudges through the woods to help Bobbi film a dance solo, part of a new project she’s calling “Friend or Foe.” It’s clearly a commentary on their strained relationship, but Chloe — just trying to get through the weekend without any drama — does her best to play along. Then Bobbi suddenly turns the camera on her, forcing years of buried tensions to spill out.




Chloe is a people pleaser and perfectionist. She’s a former dancer who gave it up long ago and has been in a deep rut ever since — like a veteran who never quite adjusted to civilian life. Seeing dance or just being around it is a major trigger. So this visit to Bobbi, who lives and breaths dance, is as anxiety-inducing as her constant ballet nightmares. She has yet to realize that in order to move on she needs to reconnect with the joy dance used to bring her and also face the reasons she decided to quit. Bobbi just might be the one person who can help.


For Bobbi, dance is life. She’s had to fight other peoples’ notions about what a dancer should be or look like — but she’s managed to stick it out, probably because she couldn’t give two sh*ts about anyone else’s idea of what “success” is. Her theatricality, which is both alluring and annoying, masks her vulnerability and loneliness. We catch glimpses of it when she’s performing her choreography. She wants to seduce Chloe back into her world — to collaborate again or just because she misses her — but she’ll have to confront her friend’s grief and anger first.



“A dancer dies twice — once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful.”

— Martha Graham


When I started developing this project a few years ago, it had been well over a decade since I boxed up all my pointe shoes for good. And yet I was still haunted by my decision to leave dance behind.


From the age of 3, my entire life had revolved around it. My obsession started with a VHS tape of Baryshnikov's 1977 Nutcracker. I was enraptured by the magic, artistry, and athleticism. By age 11, I was commuting into New York City every day to train at the School of American Ballet and performing at Lincoln Center in front of thousands of people. Around that time, I was featured in a documentary called Living a Ballet Dream - available as a bonus feature on the Barbie in The Nutcracker DVD!


The life I wanted to live seemed almost inevitable.



But it didn’t turn out that way. A domineering teacher made me dread ballet class, so in college I decided to pursue modern dance and choreography. But eking out a living in this unfamiliar world seemed implausible. So at age 22, after several years of waffling, I finally quit.


I channeled my energy into a career in film and became a successful documentary editor. I fell in love and got married. But no matter how convinced I was that leaving dance behind was the right decision, it had left a void I just couldn’t figure out how to fill.


Then I started talking to other former dancers. I discovered that this kind of struggle was both incredibly common and rarely talked about. One person told me that leaving dance was the greatest heartbreak of her life. Another said he still dreams about dancing multiple times a week. Training so hard for so long leaves a deep mark that’s impossible to shake.


FRIEND OR FOE is my attempt to give all these feelings life. And I hope that by sharing it with audiences, it can open a door to catharsis for other former dancers and for anyone who has experienced the grief of giving up or losing out on a dream.



With a wealth of experience spanning film, television, live theater, and dance, our team is well equipped to fully realize the vision for this project. 



Director Regina Sobel has spent over a decade writing, editing, and supervising award-winning films like HUMAN NATURE (nominated for three Emmys, including Best Editing) and THE QUEEN OF BASKETBALL (2022 Oscar-winner for Best Short Documentary). 


Lead actress Arielle Goldman has appeared in Steven Soderbergh's THE KNICK and Amazon’s THE MARVELOUS MRS. MAISEL and recently starred in the NYC premiere play THE BOOKSTORE at 59E59 Theaters. 


Actress and Choreographer Julia Eichten was a founding member of L.A. Dance Project and is a current member of AMOC* (American Modern Opera Company). Her work has been shown at the Lincoln Center, the Joyce Theater, and The Gardens of Versailles.


Cinematographer Rafael Roy shot the Oscar-nominated short I AM READY, WARDEN and the 2026 Sundance documentary AMERICAN DOCTOR


Producer Daniel Carbone has had a hand in projects as diverse as the Gotham Award-nominated microbudget feature WE’RE ALL GOING TO THE WORLD’S FAIR to the Oscar-shortlisted documentary FAYA DAYI.




Our team has deep roots in documentary filmmaking, which will inform our grounded, naturalistic approach to capturing Chloe and Bobbi's relationship — one that is both strained and deeply intimate. In the dance studio, these two women watched each other experience everything from wild ambition to public humiliation. Chloe can still smell Bobbi’s sweat. Bobbi can still picture Chloe’s stubborn ingrown toenail. The production design will offer glimpses of this shared history, and intimate, handheld cinematography will capture their subtle glances and gestures, like how they look at each other's bodies and anticipate each other's words.


MOOD BOARD


At the same time, we're excited to embrace the freedom that fiction allows. We've planned a surreal dream sequence and two original dances choreographed by Julia Eichten. This is where we push into a more visceral, heightened experience — where an unholy mixture of trauma and joy forces these women back together.


It's always bothered me how dance is portrayed on film. Dancers are shown to be masochistic, competitive, and f*cked up. They are those things, but there's so much more that's never explored:


The primal desire to move to music. The community. The wildly impractical dream of dedicating both your life and your body to making art.



"Do it big, do it right, and do it with style."

― Fred Astaire


We've spent the last year honing the script and putting together our team. Now we're finally ready to go into production.


We plan to shoot this film over 4 days this summer near my home in New York’s Hudson Valley — and we’re going to need a lot of help! Friends and neighbors are donating locations, costumes, props, and their time and energy to help bring this project to life. But we still have to pay our cast and crew, rent gear, and feed and house everyone.


And once the filming is done, we need money for editing, sound design, color grading, and music licensing.


Here’s how it all breaks down:


  • Cast & Crew - $13,000
  • Equipment - $3,000
  • Food, Travel, and Lodging - $7,000
  • Props, Locations & Insurance - $2,000
  • Post-Production - $5,000


All told, we think it’s going to cost $30,000 to make this film a reality. And we want to raise half of that budget here on Seed&Spark. With your help, we'll have the resources to do it with style.


And if you can't contribute financially, you can still help by spreading the word and being a part of the community we're building.

  • Follow this campaign — if we reach 250 followers on Seed&Spark, our project will be eligible for some free services.
  • Share it with anyone who you think this story might resonate with. Is there a former dancer in your life?
  • Follow us @friendorfoefilm on Instagram for behind-the-scenes footage, updates on our progress, and stories from other former dancers. We'll see you there!



FRIEND OR FOE is the start of something much bigger.


We're developing a feature film — from Chloe's beginnings as a serious ballet dancer to her finding a new path in life. And it will be inspired by the community of former dancers we hope to cultivate during this campaign and through screenings of the completed short. We're gathering stories so the world is as authentic as possible. Send us yours on Instagram at @friendorfoefilm. You don't have to be a former dancer. If there was anything you worked hard at for years before leaving it behind we want to hear about it.

Wishlist

Use the WishList to Pledge cash and Loan items - or - Make a pledge by selecting an Incentive directly.

Cast & Crew

Costs $6,500

To pay our brilliant collaborators.

Production Design

Costs $1,000

Props and costumes to bring the world of the film to life!

Equipment

Costs $1,500

Camera gear, lenses, and lights.

Post Production

Costs $2,500

Editing, sound mixing, color grading, music licensing.

Food and Lodging

Costs $3,500

We're shooting on location in the Hudson Valley and some of our team will need a place to stay!

Cash Pledge

Costs $0

About This Team

Regina is a former dancer and Emmy Award-winning filmmaker. As editor and co-writer of the feature documentary HUMAN NATURE (2020, Greenwich/PBS), she received both IDA and Emmy Award nominations for Best Editing. She served as Supervising Editor of Op-Docs, the New York Times’ short documentary series, including for the Oscar-nominated A CONCERTO IS A CONVERSATION and the Oscar-winning THE QUEEN OF BASKETBALL. Her other credits include FAIL STATE (2018, Starz), a feature documentary about inequality in higher education; OLD DOG, a verite documentary about sheep dog training in New Zealand; and QUEEN OF EARTH (2015, IFC), a narrative feature starring Elisabeth Moss.


Julia is a graduate of the Juilliard School, where they received the Hector Zaraspe Award in recognition of their choreography in 2011. Eichten was a founding member of L.A. Dance Project and is a current member of AMOC* (American Modern Opera Company). Eichten's work has been shown at the Joyce Theater, Baryshnikov Arts Center (NYC), L.A. Dance Project, The Gardens of Versailles and LUMA in Arles, FR and Lincoln Center, NYC. At Frieze Art Festival, Eichten performed an excerpt of, JULIE WITH A BEET. This smart choreographic rhythm by Eichten is the kind of dance that you always want to stumble upon and be taken by surprise with. – LA Chronicle. Eichten performed in Bobbi Jean Smith’s BROKEN THEATER to a sold out run at La Mama, NYC. Julia Eichten, in the role of stage manager, provides some much-needed comic relief. – NY Times. Eichten choreographed and performed in Long Beach Opera’s ISOLA, composed by Alyssa Weinberg and directed by George R. Miller. The linchpin of this production was the physical theater of Eichten — SF Classical Voice. Most recently, Eichten performed in Joan Jonas’ iconic Mirror Piece I & II at The Getty Museum.


Arielle is an award winning actress, writer, and filmmaker with her MFA from NYU Graduate Acting. She is currently in post-production for her third directorial film, HUNGRY HEARTS, and was recently seen in the NYC premiere plays The Bookstore at 59E59 Theaters and The Matriarchs at Theaterlab. Her short film KISS MY ASS, a pro-abortion Yiddish ghost story, can be found on FilmShortage alongside her previous film Day One. Film work: CONSIDER THE LILLIES (Best Actress, NY Women in Film), I WANT TO GO TO MOSCOW (Best Narrative, Miami Short Film Festival) & BENCH SEATS (Newport Beach FF). She can be heard alongside Dame Helen Mirren and Dominic Monighan voicing the role of Irene Adler for the Audible Original series Moriarty: The Silent Order. Theater: Let's Call Her Patty alongside Rhea Perlman and Leslie Kritzer (Lincoln Center), The Pianist (George Street), The How & The Why directed by Austin Pendelton, Embrace Plays (Pregones PRTT), The Long Christmas Dinner (Lincoln Center/ASO), Birthright (Miami New Drama). TV: The Knick (as Genevieve Everidge) directed by Steven Soderbergh, Fishkill directed by Bob Balaban & The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel (as Eliana) directed by Amy Sherman-Palladino. 


Rafael is a cinematographer and filmmaker whose work is rooted in intimate handheld observation, stories of social transformation, and the patient attention of place-based, longitudinal documentary filmmaking. He studied documentary filmmaking at the UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism, where he shot the Student Academy Award–winning film DUST RISING. His recent cinematography credits include AMERICAN DOCTOR, a 2026 Sundance World Premiere; FERGUSON RISES, winner of the 2021 Tribeca Audience Award; and I AM READY, WARDEN, a 2025 Oscar-nominated short executive produced by Sheila Nevins for MTV Films. He has also served as Director of Photography on major broadcast projects including HBO’s EYES ON THE PRIZE III and PBS FRONTLINE’s Emmy-nominated, ALASKA’S VANISHING NATIVE VILLAGES.


Daniel founded the production company Flies Collective in 2011 where he produced CHAINED FOR LIFE (2018, Kino Lorber), WE’RE ALL GOING TO THE WORLD’S FAIR (2021, Utopia), FAYA DAYI (2021, Janus/Criterion), and TENDABERRY (2024, Tribeca Film) among others. His debut feature film HIDE YOUR SMILING FACES premiered at the Berlinale and the Tribeca Film Festival in 2013. In 2016, he co-wrote and co-directed the experimental anthology film COLLECTIVE:UNCONSCIOUS. His documentary PHANTOM COWBOYS, a longitudinal study of rural American male adolescence, was released in 2018.


Adam has more than two decades of experience as an editor, writer, producer, and director of award-winning documentary films and series. He’s known for projects that combine deeply reported journalism with cinematic storytelling and has collaborated with acclaimed filmmakers such as Laura Poitras (COVER UP), Penny Lane (LISTENING TO KENNY G), and Alex Gibney (PARK AVENUE: MONEY, POWER AND THE AMERICAN DREAM). He won an Emmy for his role as Senior Producer of the Showtime documentary series YEARS OF LIVING DANGEROUSLY, which explored the climate crisis with correspondents as diverse as "60 Minutes" journalist Lesley Stahl and Hollywood icon Harrison Ford. Adam was also editor and co-writer of the 2010 Oscar-winning documentary INSIDE JOB.


His directorial debut, HUMAN NATURE, which explored the moral and ethical implications of a major scientific breakthrough in genetic engineering, was nominated for three Emmys and was a finalist for a duPont-Columbia Award.


Saeed has been dancing & choreographing up a hailstorm from the front lawn to the Great Lawn since age 3. He has worked extensively in commercial, television, and independent film production as a prop stylist, set dresser, set decorator & art director, on top of a few stints as a high-heeled extra in productions such as FX’s POSE, Younger, and Law & Order: SVU. Notable films include A SEPARATION (2021), THE SUNLIT NIGHT (2018), NEVER RARELY SOMETIMES ALWAYS (2020), CONFETTI (2021), & THE GOD COMMITTEE (2021).

Current Team

Supporters

Followers

Incentives